75. John Smoltz
74. Barry Larkin
73. Roberto Alomar (Underrated)
72. Bert Blyleven
71. Pudge Rodriguez

70. Juan Marichal
69. Frank Thomas
68. Jeff Bagwell
67. Mariano Rivera
66. Gaylord Perry
65. Eddie Murray'
64. Harmon Killebrew
63. Hank Greenberg
62. Ferguson Jenkins
61. Tony Gwynn

60. Ozzie Smith (seriously?)
59. Bob Feller
58. Robin Yount
57. Willie McCovey
56. Yogi
55. Reggie! Reggie! Reggie!
54. Wade Boggs
53. Rod Carew
52. Jackie Robinson
51. Ernie Banks