best player

[dtroitlionsfan951]

i'm gonna go with cal

 

[boogerlovejoy]

I think Calvin is the most exciting....but I think Suh is the best.

 

[upnorth]

To me, "best" means "most valuable". The guy that would affect the team most if he left/got injured would have to be Suh or Stafford

 

[kingofdetroit57]

Tough question, but I went with Suh. He's so physically dominant that he makes the entire offensive line better. Calvin is a very close second for me, but his production is dependent upon the QB, run game, and the rest of the WRs, so it's harder for him to have as big of an impact.

 

[Mitchrapp]

To me, "best" means "most valuable". The guy that would affect the team most if he left/got injured would have to be Suh or Stafford

I think you're confusing MVP with best.

 

[detrisin]

Who voted other...and who is this "other?"

 

[inkfreq]

Until Suh and the boys shut down the opposing run game, I'm going Stafford.

 

[Mitchrapp]

Who voted other...and who is this "other?"

but I won't tell.

 

[beez]

Calvin. He's the most skilled player on that team and one of the most skilled/talented players in the entire league. I owuld almost compare this with my Shaq areguement. Shag is the most dominant player in basektball history, but not even a top 5 talented center. Suh is one of the most dominant players (after a year) in the NFL but he's not a top 5 talent. Calvin might be. With a dominant qb, Calvin would be the best wr in the league imo. I'm partial to physical freaks like Calvin, Mario Williams, Andre Johnson etc. though.

 

[SoCalLions]

Equal skill IMO. Calvin is more valuable to this franchise. He's a guy who changes the dynamic of this offense. If Suh is gone, CW who commands doubles, Fairley, SLH, will do a solid job.

 

[beez]

Equal skill IMO. Calvin is more valuable to this franchise. He's a guy who changes the dynamic of this offense. If Suh is gone, CW who commands doubles, Fairley, SLH, will do a solid job.

I dont know that I agree with that entirely. Suh changed the entire defense being there last year, just as Calvin does on offense.

 

[SoCalLions]

Equal skill IMO. Calvin is more valuable to this franchise. He's a guy who changes the dynamic of this offense. If Suh is gone, CW who commands doubles, Fairley, SLH, will do a solid job.

I dont know that I agree with that entirely. Suh changed the entire defense being there last year, just as Calvin does on offense.

Suh came in the same time CW and KVB came in. You never seen Suh's effect as the sole factor. KVB and CW were the driving motivational force behind that D-line. CW commanded more doubles from the nose than Suh did as the three tech.

 

[wheels002]

Calvin is one of the best WR's in football but I voted Suh. To me I think Suh can be one of the best DT's ever. I realize he has only played one year but he has the skill and the work ethic to not just be elite but to be super elite. I still believe Suh can get better and that my friends is scary for the rest of the league. If we can keep the building blocks we have in place and add a few smaller pieces we may have something special here.

 

[tomdalton22]

Suh could be the best DT in the league. CJ is probably a top 5 WR. Stafford hasn't proven anything yet due to him missing so many games. Has to be Suh.

 

[dtroitlionsfan951]

any thought changes?

 

[lions2011]

did Suh play yesterday ?

 

[thehippo73]

did Suh play yesterday ?

Yes he did. j/k

He was held on the Tulloch interception. So even if Romo had thrown a good ball to Written, that play was coming back.

 

[dtroitlionsfan951]

did Suh play yesterday ?

haha good question....i wonder if schwartz is rotating the d-line too much....we still need some d ends tho

 

[adam86107]

did Suh play yesterday ?

Sure he played. Don't you remember the roughing the passer penalty 3rd and 3?

 

[lions2011]

did Suh play yesterday ?

Sure he played. Don't you remember the roughing the passer penalty 3rd and 3?

oh ya..he hit him in the chops....then went and kicked the beverage container all over KVB on the bench...lol