A whole lot of people who want farts to smell like roses in here. Comparing me to Chica is absolutely laughable. Chica made stupid arguments about Verlander not being an Ace in the face of absolutely all evidence to the contrary. I, on the other hand, simply point out one, simple, plainly obvious fact to everyone with two eyes and a brain and I get jumped on for "not getting on the bandwagon" I suppose because that's really the only thing that makes sense. I guess people really don't want their perfect images of JV disturbed in any way.
Fact is, his velocity is down, there is absolutely no disputing that, if you dispute that, well then I guess there's really no hope for your impartiality.
Fact is also plainly evidence throughout the history of pitching that lower velocity leads to negatives results for almost every pitcher ever in categories like K rate, HR/FB rate, and the like.
Fact is further that if those stats get worse pitching stats also get worse.
You can choose to believe this is not a concern. In fact at his current velocity it might not be. He might still be one of the top 5 pitchers in the league throwing 93-94 on average. However, a sudden dramatic decrease in a fastball is troublesome both because 1. it signifies possible injury 2. it could signify another problem that could lead to further fastball decreases 3. he's 30 and he could simply just be getting older and his FB velocity might continue to trend downward.
You might just want to believe against all the odds that JV is immune to pitching effectiveness decreases despite losing some velocity but I don't think that is reasonable.
As for rooting for JV to fail, are you serious? You can't possibly be that big a twat?
I want him to succeed as much as anyone, I hope he gets his full velocity back as that will inspire more confidence from me. He's still a top pitcher at 93-94 but I worry about whether he's "the best" at those levels. And I'm justified in that concern because the Tigers just gave him a lot of years and big money to pay him as "the best".
I'm not sure you have a handle on what is typical. Verlander averaged under 95 in 18 of his 33 starts last year, including 7 of his first 8.
Also, Verlander had less velocity last year than in any other seaon of his career. I guess velocity doesn't correlate with effective pitching quite as STRONGLY as you believe.



