Shortstop

[tycobb420]

Choose the greatest Shortstop in Tiger history...

Other board picks:

Catcher- Pudge
First base- Hank Greenberg
Third base- George Kell
RF- Al Kaline
CF- Ty Cobb
LF- Willie Horton

RHP- Justin Verlander
LHP- Hal Newhouser
The other starters- Mickey Lolich, Jack Morris, and Denny McLain
Closer- Willie Hernandez

 

[tycobb420]

Eventually, we'll get a 40 man roster...

 

[Thumb]

Haha no Mickey Stanley?

 

[tycobb420]

Ha! Maybe if it was greatest World Series shortstops!!

This is not going to be close! 10-0 Tram...can he post the first shutout?

 

[kalinecountry]

Trammell should get it easy as the vote shows so far.
Even my Tigers shortstop as a kid Harvey Kuenn, as good as he was in the 50's, finishes behind Tram. Carlos had a couple of .900 plus OPS seasons, but less time at short than Kuenn.
Trammell's 20 years and greatness as a hitter and a fundamentally perfect fielding shortstop makes him a top ten all-time imo.

 

[tycobb420]

12-0

 

[hellifino]

TyCobb, do a broadcasters/colorguy vote

 

[wolverinetiger7]

Tramm. Should be in the HOF as well.

 

[tycobb420]

ok, some smartass voted for Cruz to bust up the shutout!

 

[bavarianinnman]

Not me Trammel gets the vote here. But i was hopen to see Skeeter Barnes, or Tony Phillips then i would have had to think about it lol jk

 

[tycobb420]

Not me Trammel gets the vote here. But i was hopen to see Skeeter Barnes, or Tony Phillips then i would have had to think about it lol jk

I'll do a utility guy!

 

[bavarianinnman]

ok, lol to bad none of my favorite lose tigers will make it on the team......but for a good reason.

 

[Mitchrapp]

Btw, why no Tom Veryzer? He was a staple.

 

[jared]

I voted for Tram, but only because Travis Fryman and Tony Giarratano weren't available.

 

[bavarianinnman]

I voted for Tram, but only because Travis Fryman and Tony Giarratano weren't available.

fryman was a 3rd baseman

 

[jared]

He played over 300 games at short, too.

 

[grandy]

Where's Edgar Renteria?

 

[batcave76]

Not me Trammel gets the vote here. But i was hopen to see Skeeter Barnes, or Tony Phillips then i would have had to think about it lol jk

I'll do a utility guy!

You could get jail time for that.

 

[tycobb420]

I'll do a utility guy!

You could get jail time for that.

Esp. in Texas!

RE: Fryman (He was in the third base vote)

 

[cmlfactor]

The fact that 3 ppl voted for Cruz is hilarious. And no Neifi Perez love? Nyuk-nyuk-nyuk...